Top 10 ways Government could back our dairy farmers

2 November 2021

DairyNZ is calling on the Government to partner with dairy farmers to achieve better outcomes, invest more in research and development, and stop overloading farmers with too many regulations. 

Ten recommendations for Government have been drawn from DairyNZ’s latest ‘View from the Cowshed’ survey of 425 dairy farmers. 

DairyNZ chief executive Dr Tim Mackle says it’s critical the Government work more closely with farmers to support investment in research and development, so farmers can continue working to reduce their environmental footprint, while maintaining profitability.  

“This year’s survey indicates farmers are making on-farm changes to improve their environmental management and their workplaces, but are feeling under pressure from constant regulatory changes,” said Dr Mackle.

“We want to see more focus on ensuring regulations are fair, practical and don’t overburden farmers with too many different requirements.  

“Dairy is New Zealand’s leading export sector, employs 50,000 Kiwis and is forecast to contribute over $40 billion to our economy this year, so it’s important for our country’s success that farmers are supported to keep contributing to New Zealand.”   

57 percent of farmers surveyed said changing Government regulations are causing them stress, with 55 percent also saying perception of dairy farmers by the public and in media was also keeping them up at night.  A further 67 percent of farmers feel there isn’t enough support for farmers dealing with mental health issues.   

Positively, the survey revealed 70 percent of farmers surveyed have a Farm Environment Plan – a key tool farmers use to identify and manage environmental risks through adopting good farming practices.   

“Dairy farmers are operating in a complex environment and managing a lot of challenges. Around half previously reported being short-staffed and 45 percent don’t have the internet service they need to efficiently run farm operations,” says Dr Mackle.   

In the past two years, the Government has proposed changes to policy on freshwater management, wintering, climate change, biodiversity and vehicle taxes which would all significantly impact on farmers.   

These issues may have contributed to 32 percent of farmers saying they feel less positive about farming than 12 months ago – despite strong milk prices. Only 17 percent reported they felt more positive.   

Matamata dairy farmer Sam Owen says there isn’t one cause of mental health issues in rural communities.   

“It’s a combination of things like the labour market, changing regulations and negative media. Most people can cope with one thing, but when there are lots of things coming at you at once, it can push you over the edge.”  

The survey also provided insights into what motivates farmers to keep farming through challenges.   

Thirty-three percent of farmers reported that caring for their animals was their biggest motivation to get out of bed in the morning. A further 19 percent said providing for their families was their leading motivation.  

DairyNZ has compiled ten recommendations to address farmer concerns. The organisation will issue a copy of The View from the Cowshed report to all members of Parliament and request meetings to discuss the findings.   

“We know these issues aren’t going to go away overnight, but making these ten changes would make a real difference to the lives and wellbeing of rural New Zealanders,” Dr Mackle says.  

 Read the View from the Cowshed report here.  

 Ten ways Government could improve outcomes for dairy farmers  

1. Slow down the speed and scale of regulatory change farmers are facing 
Farmers know a shift is needed but there is too much at once, and it’s uncoordinated. Farmers are feeling overloaded. 

2. Help the sector overcome our workforce challenges  
Supporting clear pathways into dairy jobs for local and international workers.  

3. Actively partner with farmers and rural communities  
Support farming communities to drive change behind the farm gate that will lead to better environmental outcomes when it comes to the climate, water quality and biodiversity.  

4. Set a clear strategy for R&D 
We need a good strategy that is properly resourced to help us tackle the big challenges we face as a country. Science is the solution to many of our challenges.  

5. Proudly champion our world-leading split gas approach internationally  
Advocate for split gas and the exploration of alternative metrics like GWP* that better reflect the warming impact of methane.  

6. Invest significantly in improved digital connectivity  
Our rural communities don’t have adequate broadband or mobile coverage. This is an enabler that will unlock multiple benefits for our sector.  

7. Give farmers certainty and rule out DIN 
Categorically rule out consideration of a national bottom line for Dissolved Inorganic Nitrogen (DIN). There are better ways to achieve the freshwater outcomes we all want.  

8. Work with us on biosecurity 
Work with industry to prioritise implementing recommendations from the independent review of M. bovis, address essential system gaps and work with industry to enable a streamlined, efficient model for biosecurity readiness and responses.  

9. Remove the ute tax 
Exempt farmers from the ‘ute tax’ until low emission alternatives are readily available in New Zealand that are fit-for-purpose on farm.  

10. Rework the National Policy Statement for Indigenous Biodiversity  
In consultation with farmers, ensure the NPS will meet our biodiversity objectives, while also working for landowners. 
 

Note: The View from the Cowshed report was based on an opt-in survey of 425 dairy farmers carried out in April to May 2021. Weighting was used to ensure that the results matched the herd size and regional distribution of farms nationally as closely as possible.

Media contact

Allanah Jarman
Senior media specialist
Ph 021 240 6614
allanah.jarman@dairynz.co.nz